top of page

From Design Decisions to Deciding Whether That’s Poo or Chocolate

Nov 5
11 min read

Updated: 15 hours ago



This is my second maternity leave, so you’d think I’d have this whole stepping-away-from-work business figured out by now. I’ve done it before. I had a baby, took some time off, returned to work and, somewhat surprisingly, discovered that I could still do my job. I hadn’t forgotten how to design a service, facilitate a workshop or explain for the 400th time why we probably shouldn’t solve a usability problem by adding another tooltip.

I don’t even remember particularly struggling with the transition back. I found my feet, got stuck back in and carried on with my career. No dramatic loss of professional competence. No identity crisis in front of a Miro board.


And yet, here I am, five months into maternity leave number two, occasionally wondering whether I’ll still be any good at my job when I go back. Because apparently having actual, lived evidence that everything will probably be fine isn’t enough to stop my brain from catastrophising.


Stakeholder management vs managing tiny dictators

Before maternity leave, my days were filled with research findings, stakeholder meetings, workshops, prototypes, accessibility considerations and solving complicated problems. Now, I’m still doing most of those things, just with a slightly different audience.


Stakeholder management? Try explaining to a three year old why she can’t have Starbursts for breakfast.


Prioritisation? Deciding whether the overflowing washing basket, crying baby or suspicious silence from the toddler requires my immediate attention.


Conflict resolution? Two tiny humans screaming because one wants to be picked up and the other wants me to put the first one down.


And as for working with challenging requirements, I’ve recently been informed that a sandwich cut into triangles is completely unacceptable because it was supposed to be squares, despite yesterday’s squares being equally offensive. At least my colleagues generally accepted a rationale.


But there’s something quite strange about stepping away from a profession you’ve spent years building a career in. When so much of your working life revolves around solving problems, making decisions and generally feeling like you know what you’re doing, suddenly not doing any of those things professionally can leave you feeling a little disconnected. It’s not that I think I’ve forgotten how to design. Years of experience don’t just evaporate because I’ve spent several months watching Bluey and Googling whether a baby’s poo is supposed to look like that.


It’s more about confidence.


Will I still trust my judgement? Will I walk into a complicated problem and know where to start? Will everyone have moved on to some revolutionary new way of working that I’ve completely missed? Will I return to discover Figma has been replaced by an completely new AI tool that generates entire services from a single prompt and my only remaining responsibility is to approve a shade of blue?



Maternity leave is not a 12-month personal development sprint

Before this starts sounding like one of those LinkedIn posts about how I used my maternity leave to launch three businesses, learn fluent Spanish and become a thought leader in AI, I should probably clarify something...I absolutely do not think anyone should feel obligated to spend parental leave keeping up with their industry. You’re on leave. That’s the whole point.


The last thing anyone needs when they’re surviving on broken sleep, three times re-heated coffee and the emotional rollercoaster of just trying to leave the house (not before you’ve cleaned up the second poonami of the morning and we have to find the purple princess skirt, not the pink one), is the added pressure of trying to complete a Coursera certificate before lunchtime.


And yet, I’ve realised that completely switching off the part of my brain that enjoys design doesn’t particularly appeal to me either. I like making things, solving problems and figuring out how stuff works. I also quite like occasionally thinking about something that doesn’t involve feeding schedules, laundry or whether we’ve got enough nappies to last us until tomorrow morning.


It’s nice to remember I have interests beyond keeping small humans alive, even if keeping small humans alive is currently taking up approximately 97% of my available brain capacity. So I’ve been finding little ways to keep one foot in the design world, without turning maternity leave into another job.


Things I’m doing to keep my design brain from turning into mashed potato

I should stress that none of these activities form part of a carefully considered professional development strategy. There are no SMART goals, no success metrics and absolutely no retrospective scheduled for the end of maternity leave. They’re just things I’ve found myself doing because I enjoy them and because occasionally it’s nice to feel like I can still hold a conversation about something other than sleep regressions.


1. Making things nobody asked me to make

One of the things I’ve enjoyed most is creating things simply because I can.

I’ve been playing around with digital products, experimenting with ideas and giving myself little creative projects that may or may not ever see the light of day.

There’s something incredibly liberating about designing without a stakeholder, a deadline, a backlog or someone asking whether we could “just make it pop a bit more.”

No acceptance criteria. No sign-off process. No 45-minute discussion about whether a button should say “Continue” or “Next”. No one appearing halfway through to announce that their cousin has used an app once and has some thoughts on the user experience.


Some ideas have been genuinely interesting. Others have probably only seemed like strokes of genius because I thought of them during a 3am feed. But it’s been nice to experiment without needing to justify the time spent or produce something commercially viable.


For anyone else on parental leave: Make something completely unrelated to your day job. A website, an illustration, a ridiculous app idea, whatever takes your fancy. It doesn’t need to be useful, impressive or portfolio-worthy. In fact, the less pressure you put on it, the more enjoyable it’ll probably be.


2. Falling down the AI rabbit hole (send help)

AI is moving at such an alarming pace that I’m half expecting to return to work and discover my laptop has been promoted in my absence. So I’ve been spending time experimenting with different AI tools, learning more about how the technology actually works and thinking about what it means for interaction and product design.


I’m not trying to become an AI expert overnight, although my search history might suggest otherwise. One minute I’m learning the difference between machine learning and generative AI, and the next I’m reading about autonomous agents and how LLMs actually work, wondering whether I’ll ever actually catch up and get my head around the rapidly expanding topic.


It’s also been surprisingly refreshing to be a beginner again. When you’ve worked in design for years, you get used to having opinions, knowing where to start and being able to confidently explain your decisions. Exploring something unfamiliar means asking basic questions, getting things wrong and occasionally realising you’ve spent 20 minutes confidently misunderstanding something.


A humbling experience. Highly recommend.


For anyone else on parental leave: Pick one thing happening in your industry that genuinely interests you and have a play. You don’t need to become an expert or announce your learning journey to LinkedIn. You can just learn something because it’s interesting. Revolutionary, I know.


3. Continuing to be personally offended by bad design

I don’t think designers ever truly switch this off. Even on maternity leave, I still find myself mentally redesigning frustrating experiences, questioning why something requires seven clicks and getting disproportionately annoyed when a form asks me for information I’ve already provided. Except now I’m often navigating these experiences one-handed, while holding a baby, being asked 47 questions by a toddler and trying to remember why I picked up my phone in the first place.


Which, as it turns out, is a fairly effective usability test.


I’ve gained a whole new appreciation for clear content, accessible interactions and services that don’t require my undivided attention for 20 consecutive minutes.

Because sometimes your users aren’t sitting at a desk with a cup of coffee, ready to give your beautifully designed service their full attention. Sometimes they’re standing in a kitchen, covered in baby sick, trying to book an appointment while someone shouts that their sock feels weird.


And if your service requires them to remember a six-digit code sent to an email account they can’t access without losing their progress, they’re probably going to hate you.


For anyone else on parental leave: Notice the things you use every day. What works? What drives you mad? What would you change? You don’t have to redesign every bad experience you encounter, although resisting the urge is admittedly difficult.


4. Reading things without pretending I’m studying for an exam

I’ve accepted that I won’t keep up with every design trend, industry announcement, newsletter or article while I’m away.


To be fair, I wasn’t managing that particularly well when I was working full-time either.

But if something catches my attention, I’ll read it. Sometimes it’s an article about accessibility or AI, sometimes it’s a discussion about how design roles are evolving, and sometimes it’s a link that sends me down a rabbit hole until I emerge 40 minutes later with 12 tabs open and no recollection of what I originally wanted to know.


I don’t have a reading schedule, a target number of articles or a beautifully organised Notion database of professional insights. I have approximately 300 saved posts that I’ll probably never look at again, which feels much more realistic.


For anyone else on parental leave: Follow your curiosity rather than trying to consume everything. Save interesting things, read what appeals to you and ignore the rest. The industry will survive without you knowing about every new Figma plugin.


5. Becoming the user research participant (and trying not to be annoying)

After years of planning research sessions, writing discussion guides, observing participants and trying desperately not to ask leading questions, I’ve decided to spend some time on the other side of the research fence.


I’ve been signing up for user research and usability testing, which has been a surprisingly interesting way to stay connected to the world of design. It’s a slightly strange experience going from asking the questions to answering them, particularly when you can practically hear the research objectives behind every prompt.

“And what would you expect to happen if you clicked that?” Well, I can see what you’re trying to validate here, and actually, I have a few thoughts about your research methodology…


Nobody asked, Claire. Just click the damn button.


But genuinely, it’s been a useful reminder of what it’s like to be a participant. The awkwardness of thinking aloud, the temptation to give the answer you think the researcher wants and that horrible moment when someone asks what you’re thinking and you realise your brain has temporarily vacated the premises.


It’s also made me more conscious of how much we ask of people during research, particularly when they’re trying to articulate thoughts about something they’ve never encountered before.


And yes, occasionally you get paid for it, which is a nice bonus. Although I’m not sure “professional button clicker” is the career pivot I’m looking for just yet.


For anyone else on parental leave: Sign up to participate in user research. It’s a great opportunity to experience the process from the other side and reflect on your own practice. Just resist the urge to turn the debrief into an unsolicited critique of the research plan.


6. Doing absolutely none of the above

Possibly the most important point on this entire list.


Some days I feel creative, motivated and genuinely excited to explore something new.

Other days, I’ve been awake since 4am, the house looks like it’s been burgled and getting everyone dressed before midday feels worthy of a national award. On those days, my professional development consists of successfully locating the TV remote and remembering to eat lunch. And that’s absolutely fine.


I’m not trying to prove I’m still employable. I’m not trying to return to work with six new qualifications, a side business generating passive income and a personal brand centred around how I optimised my maternity leave. I’m doing these things because I enjoy them, and because they help me maintain a connection to something that’s been a big part of my life for a long time. If I don’t feel like doing them, I don’t. My current project managers are four months and three years old, and neither has much respect for my planned schedule anyway.


You don’t lose years of experience just because you’ve spent a year discussing bodily functions....This is the bit I occasionally need to remind myself of.


The years I’ve spent designing services haven’t disappeared. The research sessions, workshops, stakeholder conversations, accessibility lessons, difficult decisions and projects that went spectacularly wrong are all still there, safely stored somewhere in my brain alongside the lyrics to every children’s song I’ve heard 600 times.

And I’ve already proved this to myself once.


When I returned from my first maternity leave, I didn’t have to relearn how to be a designer. I got back into the rhythm of work, caught up on what I’d missed and reacquainted myself with the various systems, processes and acronyms that seem to multiply whenever you’re not looking.


The actual ability to do my job was still there. I imagine it’ll be much the same this time.

I’ll probably be rusty. I’ll have forgotten some shortcuts. I’ll spend an unreasonable amount of time trying to remember where things are saved, and I’ll almost certainly ask a question that was answered in a meeting six months earlier.


But being out of practice isn’t the same as being incapable.


And perhaps that’s worth remembering for anyone returning from parental leave or an extended career break.


You’re not starting again. You’re just getting back into it.


Perhaps I’ll return with a few new skills after all

Now, I’m not about to suggest that maternity leave is secretly an intensive leadership development programme, because that feels like the sort of thing someone would put on LinkedIn alongside a photograph of themselves looking thoughtfully out of a window.

But I do think there are things you learn from spending time away from your usual working environment.


For starters, I’ve become exceptionally good at prioritisation.

When you’ve got a crying baby, a toddler who urgently needs help putting a sticker on something and a washing machine making a noise that suggests it’s about to launch itself into orbit, you quickly learn what actually needs your attention.


I’ve also become considerably more comfortable with “good enough”, which is probably a useful skill in an industry where we can spend three meetings debating a component that was perfectly functional two iterations ago. My negotiation skills have improved too. If I can convince a three-year-old that wearing shoes is a reasonable requirement for leaving the house, I feel fairly confident I can handle a challenging stakeholder conversation.


And I’ve spent a lot of time experiencing services from a different perspective.

Healthcare, retail, government services, booking systems, apps and online forms all look rather different when you’re tired, distracted, short on time and trying to do everything with one hand.


It’s a useful reminder that the people using the things we design aren’t always sitting at a desk, fully focused, with unlimited patience and a stable internet connection.

Sometimes they’re standing in a kitchen with a baby on their hip, desperately trying to complete a form before someone starts crying. And sometimes that someone is them.


I’m not suggesting this automatically makes me a better designer, but I’d like to think I’ll return with some different perspectives, a few new ideas and perhaps a slightly lower tolerance for unnecessarily complicated user journeys.

Although, to be fair, that tolerance was already pretty low.


So, will I still be good at my job?

I suppose that’s the question I started with, and the answer is almost certainly yes.

I know this because I’ve done it before. I know this because years of experience don’t vanish overnight, and I know this because being a designer is about considerably more than knowing your way around a design tool.


For me, staying “in the zone” isn’t really about keeping up with every industry development or making sure I’m professionally productive throughout maternity leave. It’s about staying curious, making things when I feel like it, exploring ideas and occasionally using the part of my brain that enjoys solving problems that don’t involve missing shoes or unexplained sticky substances.


But I also think it’s important to say that none of this is necessary.

If you spend your entire parental leave doing absolutely nothing related to work, that’s brilliant. If you want to learn something new, experiment with ideas or keep in touch with your industry, that’s brilliant too.


There isn’t a correct way to do it, and nobody should feel the need to produce a portfolio of achievements to justify the time they’ve spent away. As for me, I’ll carry on experimenting, reading, making things and occasionally wondering whether I’ll remember how to do my job. Because apparently, even the second time around, that little bit of doubt doesn’t disappear completely.


But I know I’ll find my feet again.


And perhaps rather than worrying about whether I’ll still be the designer I was before maternity leave, I should be a little more curious about the designer I’ll be when I return.

Worst-case scenario, I’ll have forgotten a few Figma shortcuts.


Best-case scenario, I’ll come back with fresh ideas, a different perspective and an almost superhuman ability to manage unreasonable stakeholder demands.


After all, I’ve spent the best part of a year negotiating with someone who once had a complete meltdown because I peeled their banana.


I think I’ll be fine.

 
 
 

Comments


Lavender brain with white wordmark.png

overthinkingprofessionally.com

  • LinkedIn

Writing from Ormskrik, West Lancashire

bottom of page